Book Review: Snow Treasure by Marie McSwigan
Snow Treasure
by Marie McSwigan
The forward to Snow Treasure says:
On June 28,1940, nearly a year after World War II broke out in Europe, the Norwegian freighter BOMMA reached Baltimore with a cargo of gold bullion worth $9,000,000…..The gold, it was reported, had been slipped past Nazi sentries by Norwegian boys and girls!…So that no harm might come to the brave children, the captain would not tell the location of the fiord (where the freighter hid and to which the children brought their sleds).
For many years the story was believed true. But over 60 years later, there is no proof that it ever really happened. We do not know. But we do know that the story captures tjhe courage of many children who, caught up in the war, have helped their country in a time of great danger.
Nazi Germany invaded and occupied Norway in April 1940. This story tells of a group of 25 schoolchildren, ranging in age from 8 to 12, who purportedly moved several tons of gold from a hiding spot which had been carved from the forest and the snow, directly past a Nazi encampment to a designated spot where they buried the gold and built snowmen as markers. This went on for weeks and was supposedly never detected even though the children were mere feet from Nazi soldiers daily.
It’s very difficult for me to believe that this story is true. No doubt the freighter captain used it to deflect attention from the actual resistance fighters who loaded the ship. If it was true, after the war the children would certainly have told people and there would be much oral history to support it.
Tidbit: The freighter Bomma has been renamed in the story as the Cleng Peerson, a little bit of irony since Peerson was a pioneer who led the first group of Norwegians to emigrate to the United States.
I couldn’t warm to Snow Treasure, “a story of courage and adventure”, although I’m aware that it’s considered a minor classic. Part of that is the writing style which seemed dated and a little clunky. In addition, I think it undermines the awareness of the true danger that ones in Nazi occupied countries faced.
Also, I was slightly rankled by the way that the elderly servant Per Garson spoke. His speech had the cadence of a Norwegian speaking English – an effect that was unnecessary and out of place, since he would have been speaking Norwegian like everyone else, and not a second language.
Written in 1942 and published just months after the U.S. entered WWII, it’s a fine piece of war propaganda that encourages all good little boys & girls to support their country during wartime. It no doubt felt to many a child who collected tinfoil & weeded a victory garden like a warm pat on the back for being part of the war effort.
But I’m still only lukewarm.
Reading challenges: This book satisfies five of my reading challenges:Ten Categories Challenge (older than I am), Decades Challenge, the New To Me Authors Challenge, the Support Your Local Library, and 100+.
Link for Canadian readers:
Snow Treasure
Or, even better, buy from an independent book seller.
P.S. The links are affiliate links so I will receive a small percentage of any purchase you make after clicking through from this blog.
Technorati Tags: Marie McSwigan, Snow Treasure, Nazi occupation of Norway, gold bullion, Bomma, Cleng Peerson
I’ve never heard of this book or the “myth” (is it fair to call it a myth?) on which it’s based, I consider myself a mild afficiando of World War II information! I’ll be Googling around about this one, though I’ll take your review to heart and may skip the actual book.
I think it’s very fair to call it a “myth”!
Many others have really liked the book so if your interest lies in this area, you might want to read it. It’s very quick to read (an evening) because it’s YA. I just couldn’t – well, “warm” to it, as I said.
Like the first commenter (commentor?) I have never heard of the book or the myth. It’s an interesting idea but I don’t think I’ll be searching for the book myself.
This was a book that I enjoyed reading aloud to my sons on several occasions because it gave them a child-size bite of WWII history to prime them for future studies. Twenty and Ten was another wonderful book for this purpose.
I’ve not heard of Twenty and Ten. Perhaps I’ll have a look for it. I seem to be getting an awful lot of WWII settings lately in my reading.